Just a few notes about Realtor commissions, something to read when deciding between an agent and FSBO 177

Posted by Admin2 Mon, 24 May 2010 10:17:00 GMT

Originally published by Mark S Nadel and since widely circulated.  The article http://bit.ly/cym7Oz was first posted on the AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies website, about the flaws in the commission structure used by Realtors.  If you're considering hiring a real estate agent versus going FSBO, at least give this a read.  At a minimum it will allow you to feel empowered to negotiate the commissions that you're paying to list on the MLS.  Or, you could try listing on http://choicea.com as an FSBO first. 

Summary: While real estate brokers have long set their fee as a straight percentage of a home’s sale price, this formula is an anomaly and a primary reason why such fees may be inflated by more than $30 billion annually. Although competitive pressures ordinarily produce a fee structure reflecting costs, real estate broker commissions are strangely unrelated to either the quantity or quality of the service rendered or even to the value provided. Rather, this fee has been based solely on the price of the home. (It is as if tax preparers set their fee as a flat percentage of a client’s gross income, irrespective of how difficult the return was to prepare or how much their efforts saved the taxpayer). Oddly, not only is there no evidence that it is any more costly to sell higher-priced homes than median-priced properties, but it is possible that the opposite may be true! Furthermore, the straight percentage fee formula creates little incentive for real estate agents to provide home buyers or sellers with additional value.

policy advisor with the federal
government in Washington,
D.C. He has published articles
on public policy issues in law
journals at Harvard, Yale, and
Stanford, and in the Wall Street
Journal. He is a graduate of
Amherst College (1978) and
Harvard Law School (1981).
This article began as a
footnote to in his 2000 analysis
of how new communication
technologies can dramatically
improve the consumer product
selection process
policy advisor with the federal
government in Washington,
D.C. He has published articles
on public policy issues in law
journals at Harvard, Yale, and
Stanford, and in the Wall Street
Journal. He is a graduate of
Amherst College (1978) and
Harvard Law School (1981).
This article began as a
footnote to in his 2000 analysis
of how new communication
technologies can dramatically
improve the consumer product
selection p

A link to the complete study can be found here:

 http://realestate.cornell.edu/crer/images/uploads/article/Abridged_RateStructure_Nadel.pdf

  1. Loretta Engel {{count}} days later:

    If only I had a nickel for each time I came here.. Amazing read.

  2. cheapest life insurance {{count}} days later:
  3. affordable car insurance {{count}} days later:
  4. insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  5. blackjack online {{count}} days later:
  6. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  7. autoinsurance {{count}} days later:
  8. private health insurance {{count}} days later:
  9. Marcella Ray {{count}} days later:

    If only more than 74 people would hear this.

  10. discount health insurance {{count}} days later:
  11. instant carinsurance quote {{count}} days later:
  12. health insurance online {{count}} days later:
  13. home insurance {{count}} days later:
  14. Sang Wyatt {{count}} days later:

    If only more people would hear this!

  15. business insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  16. life insurance companies {{count}} days later:
  17. Katie Russo {{count}} days later:

    You have done it again. Superb writing.

  18. ketwbqeyipe {{count}} days later:
  19. cheapest car insurance {{count}} days later:
  20. business insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  21. buy xenical {{count}} days later:
  22. order cialis {{count}} days later:
  23. term life insurance {{count}} days later:
  24. Emmanuel York {{count}} days later:

    Hah I am honestly the first reply to this amazing article!?

  25. online insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  26. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  27. term life insurance {{count}} days later:
  28. Edwardo Carver {{count}} days later:

    If I had a penny for every time I came here… Great read!

  29. Sanford Jung {{count}} days later:

    If only more people could hear this..

  30. life insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  31. health insurance companies {{count}} days later:
  32. healthinsurance {{count}} days later:
  33. health insurance providers {{count}} days later:
  34. zithromax online {{count}} days later:
  35. home insurance companies {{count}} days later:
  36. health insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  37. low cost health insurance {{count}} days later:
  38. Pharmd474 {{count}} days later:

    Hello! ceakfkf interesting ceakfkf site!

  39. Pharme568 {{count}} days later:

    Very nice site! cheap viagra

  40. Pharmd271 {{count}} days later:

    Very nice site! [url=http://ypxoiea.com/qyrvaq/2.html]cheap cialis[/url]

  41. Pharma435 {{count}} days later:

    Very nice site! cheap cialis http://ypxoiea.com/qyrvaq/4.html

  42. Pharme824 {{count}} days later:

    Very nice site!

  43. Pharmd132 {{count}} days later:
  44. term business insurance {{count}} days later:
  45. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  46. home insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  47. blackjack game {{count}} days later:
  48. buy levitra {{count}} days later:
  49. health insurance for individuals {{count}} days later:
  50. buy propecia {{count}} days later:
  51. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  52. business insurance companies {{count}} days later:
  53. life insurance companies {{count}} days later:
  54. life insurance quote {{count}} days later:
  55. buy levitra online {{count}} days later:
  56. car insurance quote {{count}} days later:
  57. cheap-levitra {{count}} days later:
  58. online casino black jack {{count}} days later:
  59. order levitra {{count}} days later:
  60. auto insurance com {{count}} days later:
  61. buy propecia {{count}} days later:
  62. buy levitra online {{count}} days later:
  63. viagra without prescription {{count}} days later:
  64. Hello! cialis , viagra , viagra , cialis ,

  65. homeowners insurance {{count}} days later:
  66. cheap health insurance {{count}} days later:
  67. vehicle insurance {{count}} days later:
  68. buy levitra {{count}} days later:
  69. life insurance quote {{count}} days later:
  70. health insurance cost {{count}} days later:
  71. automobile insurance {{count}} days later:
  72. health insurance plan {{count}} days later:
  73. cheap car insurance {{count}} days later:
  74. car insurance comparison {{count}} days later:
  75. home insurance quote {{count}} days later:
  76. ratings health insurance {{count}} days later:
  77. health insurance {{count}} days later:
  78. automobile insurance {{count}} days later:
  79. business insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  80. term home insurance {{count}} days later:
  81. viagra without prescription {{count}} days later:
  82. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  83. business insurance quote {{count}} days later:
  84. buy zithromax {{count}} days later:
  85. order cialis {{count}} days later:
  86. order levitra {{count}} days later:
  87. vehicle insurance {{count}} days later:
  88. affordable life insurance {{count}} days later:
  89. cheap insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  90. auto insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  91. private health insurance costs {{count}} days later:
  92. health insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  93. Hello! cialis , cialis online ,

  94. auto insurance companies {{count}} days later:
  95. automobile insurance {{count}} days later:
  96. health insurances {{count}} days later:
  97. cheapest car insurance {{count}} days later:
  98. car insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  99. cheap business insurance {{count}} days later:
  100. cheap-levitra {{count}} days later:
  101. discount health insurance {{count}} days later:
  102. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  103. car insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  104. safeauto {{count}} days later:
  105. Hello! viagra , viagra ,

  106. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  107. motorcycle insurance quote {{count}} days later:
  108. Hello! cialis , cialis ,

  109. motorcycle insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  110. auto insurance rates {{count}} days later:
  111. cheap car insurance {{count}} days later:
  112. life insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  113. cheapest car insurance {{count}} days later:
  114. health insurance companies {{count}} days later:
  115. cheap auto insurance {{count}} days later:
  116. affordable home insurance {{count}} days later:
  117. self employed health insurance {{count}} days later:
  118. automobile insurance {{count}} days later:
  119. order levitra {{count}} days later:
  120. buy xenical {{count}} days later:
  121. classic car insurance {{count}} days later:
  122. health insurance quotes {{count}} days later:
  123. life insurance {{count}} days later:
  124. Hello! buy cialis , viagra , viagra ,

  125. auto ins {{count}} days later:
  126. cheap life insurance {{count}} days later:
  127. self employed health insurance {{count}} days later:
  128. cheap home insurance {{count}} days later:
  129. home insurance {{count}} days later:
  130. business insurance companies about 1 month later:
  131. blackjack games about 1 month later:
  132. Pharmg216 about 1 month later:

    Hello! ekddbek interesting ekddbek site!

  133. Pharmf966 about 1 month later:

    Very nice site! cheap viagra

  134. Pharma554 about 1 month later:

    Very nice site! [url=http://opeyixa.com/rvqatx/2.html]cheap cialis[/url]

  135. Pharmk542 about 1 month later:

    Very nice site! cheap cialis http://opeyixa.com/rvqatx/4.html

  136. Pharme491 about 1 month later:
  137. car insurance comparison about 1 month later:
  138. buy levitra online about 1 month later:
  139. home insurance quote about 1 month later:
  140. car insurance about 1 month later:
  141. buy zoloft about 1 month later:
  142. zithromax online about 1 month later:
  143. auto car insurance about 1 month later:
  144. life insurance companies about 1 month later:
  145. auto insurance com about 1 month later:
  146. whole motorcycle insurance about 1 month later:
  147. cheapest car insurance about 1 month later:
  148. new york auto insurance quotes about 1 month later:
  149. cheap life insurance about 1 month later:
  150. car insurance com about 1 month later:
  151. order viagra about 1 month later:
  152. cheap auto insurance about 1 month later:
  153. Dyepekahhergy about 1 month later:

    viagra equivalent herbal tablets viagra tia herb viagra
    sub for viagra

  154. auto insurance about 1 month later:
  155. private health insurance policies about 1 month later:
  156. motorcycle insurance companies about 1 month later:
  157. health insurance about 1 month later:
  158. cheap home insurance about 1 month later:
  159. life insurance companies about 1 month later:
  160. discount health insurance about 1 month later:
  161. order levitra about 1 month later:
  162. order viagra online about 1 month later:
  163. health insurance companies about 1 month later:
  164. purchase acomplia about 1 month later:
  165. accutane about 1 month later:
  166. automobile insurance about 1 month later:
  167. purchase acomplia about 1 month later:
  168. buy acomplia online about 1 month later:
  169. cheap aciphex online about 1 month later:
  170. auto ins about 1 month later:
  171. purchase acomplia about 1 month later:
  172. life insurance quote about 1 month later:
  173. aciphex online about 1 month later: